Which clauses require particular care when signing a B2B contract? How can you protect your interests?

HR, Payroll & Social Insurance You will read this in 2 minutes Last updated:
Marek Przybylski
Which clauses require particular care when signing a B2B contract? How can you protect your interests?

Free online invoicing software

with KSeF support

Micro, small and medium-sized enterprises represent the overwhelming majority of businesses operating in Poland and generate the lion’s share of domestic jobs. Yet these companies often face the greatest business risks, frequently depending on much larger entities. Such risks may lie not only in daily operations, but also in B2B contracts, whose clauses often cause future legal and financial problems. This particularly concerns contracts with an imbalance between the parties. In this article, we answer “Which clauses require particular care when signing a B2B contract?” and identify ways to protect your interests in B2B cooperation.

Freedom of contract – where are its limits and what should you consider when concluding a B2B contract? How can you protect your interests in B2B cooperation?

The Civil Code’s principle of freedom of contract, underpinning all commercial dealings and extending to B2B contracts, has significant limitations, specified in Article 3531 of the Civil Code.

This provision states: “Parties concluding a contract may arrange their legal relationship as they see fit, provided its content or purpose does not contradict the characteristics (nature) of that relationship, the law or the principles of social coexistence”.

Although entrepreneurs can freely shape their contracts, the provisions must not violate the characteristics of the relationship, statutory law or the principles of social coexistence.

Increasingly, academic views and case law identify clauses whose inclusion in a B2B contract may justify finding that freedom of contract has been exceeded. Practice shows this particularly concerns unequal parties, where a smaller entity with weaker negotiating power, fewer resources or imposed time pressure accepts ready-made clauses imposed by a larger company.

Which B2B clauses deserve particular care? Here is our list!

Accounting that understands your business

Accounting that understands your business

Leave your email address and receive guides supporting your business’s growth once a week

A unilateral right to change B2B contract terms

The first clause that should not appear in a B2B contract and may be challenged is a unilateral right to change contractual terms.

One party being unable to terminate the contract or negotiate its terms is a textbook example of contractual imbalance. A contract must not create an extremely one-sided relationship, and any change should require written form and an amendment signed by both entities.

Automatic contract renewal – is this clause allowed?

Automatic renewal for another period without the possibility of negotiation or termination can be a trap. Avoid such clauses, particularly because renewal may mean worse terms and continued payments for services you no longer need. This may create a risk for your business that proper B2B contract drafting can easily avoid.

Contractual penalties – grossly excessive and imposed on only one party

Contractual penalties regularly appear in B2B contracts, and generally there is nothing wrong with that. The problem arises when penalties are grossly excessive and threaten only one party for the slightest failings, while the other faces no consequences for any breach.

A non-compete clause without compensation

B2B contracts preventing a party from competing both during and after the contract should generally provide compensation. No compensation for such a loyalty commitment opens the way to challenging the clause.

The non-compete provision itself should be as precise as possible, particularly concerning compensation and duration.

Beware B2B clauses bearing the characteristics of employment!

Last week on the TaxCoach blog, we reported that planned reforms giving the National Labour Inspectorate administrative powers to convert B2B and civil-law contracts into employment contracts have, for now, been suspended by the Prime Minister.

This does not mean contract scrutiny has disappeared! The National Labour Inspectorate is already intensifying examination of relationships where B2B and mandate contracts in practice meet employment characteristics. PIP reform remains an adopted National Recovery Plan milestone, meaning changes should still be expected.

We therefore recall that including provisions characteristic of employment in a B2B contract is risky. Clauses providing for services under the other party’s strict direction, combined with Labour Code benefits, may result in a court reclassifying the B2B contract as employment.

If this article interested you, explore our HR and payroll services and read how we can help you:

If this article interested you, explore our HR and payroll services and read how we can help you:

Summary

Which clauses require particular care when signing a B2B contract? How can you protect your interests?


None of the B2B provisions described automatically invalidates the entire transaction, but they may be grounds for a challenge because they conflict with the principles of social coexistence or the nature of the legal relationship and breach balance between the parties.


Pay particular attention to clauses granting unilateral changes to contractual terms or allowing tacit contract renewal.


Also watch for grossly excessive penalties imposed on only one party or broad non-compete restrictions without appropriate financial compensation. B2B contracts resembling employment are a separate issue and may subsequently be reclassified as employment contracts by a court.

Interested in this article?

Enter your email address and once a week you will receive practical materials and tips to help you grow your business.

Consultant

Book a free consultation

Grow your business with accounting combined with advisory services:

Help with starting a business
Support from a tax adviser
Support from a chief financial officer

or